8-21 April: EU Ignores Its Burma Sanction Benchmarks

April 22, 2013

Today, the EU is likely to lift most of the remaining sanctions on Burma allowing a glut of investment by European companies, despite the benchmarks set out last year not being met. In April last year, the EU suspended sanctions for one year and outlined conditions that must be met if they were to be lifted completely. These benchmarks included the unconditional release of political prisoners, an end to armed conflict, recognition of the status of Rohingya, and improved humanitarian access to conflict-affected zones. These conditions are being ignored.

Firstly, there remain over 200 political prisoners in Burma and those who have been released face restrictions, for example, not being issued passports. While there have been some limited steps towards the release of those remaining with the establishment of a review board to determine who is still a political prisoner and thus release them, this review board has so far lacked any substance. Furthermore, as pointed out by the Special Rapporteur for the situation of human rights in Burma, Tomás Ojea Quintana, Rohingya prisoners in Arakan State are being tortured and left out of the review board’s list of political prisoners.

Secondly, the armed conflict in Kachin State has become considerably worse since April of last year. A major Burma Army offensive since Christmas has compounded the terrible humanitarian situation in northern Burma. Helicopters and jets dropping shells that kill innocent Kachin civilians and the arbitrary arrest and torture of suspected Kachin soldiers do not represent progress in ending armed conflict. In recent weeks, there have also been more Burma Army attacks on the Shan State Army – North in Shan State.

Thirdly, the welfare of Rohingyas has seriously deteriorated. Two bouts of violence in Arakan State last year have left around 125,000 refugees, mostly Rohingyas. The government’s commission to investigate the violence does not include any Rohingyas while protection for people in Arakan State, for both Rohingya Muslims and Arakan Buddhists, is inadequate.

The fourth benchmark is improved humanitarian access for those in need. For those displaced by the violence in Arakan State, the living conditions in the refugee camps are awful. As Valerie Amos, the UN Under-Secretary General for Humanitarian Affairs and Emergency Relief Coordinator, said after a visit in December, “I saw thousands of people in overcrowded, sub-standard shelter with poor sanitation. They don’t have jobs, children are not in school and they can’t leave the camp because their movement is restricted.” In Kachin State, the government routinely delays or blocks humanitarian access to Internally Displaced Persons camps.

Last year, the suspension of sanctions was an acknowledgment that there were dangers of backsliding. “Those changes are not yet irreversible, which is why it is right to suspend rather than lift sanctions for good,” said UK Prime Minister, David Cameron, at the time. The premature lifting of sanctions by the EU gives the signal to the Burma government that it doesn’t really matter what is happening in the country, as they will always be rewarded. As Eva Kusuma Sundari, President of the ASEAN Inter-Parliamentary Myanmar Caucus and an Indonesian Member of Parliament succinctly summarises, “Permanently lifting EU sanctions now would be sending the wrong message.” The United Nationalities Federal Council (UNFC), an alliance of non-state armed groups, also warns of the dangers of lifting the sanctions prematurely, “If the EU chooses to remove all sanctions, it will reduce its ability to work to promote, peace, democracy, and human rights in Burma.”

At a recent township administrative office meeting in Rangoon Region, it was announced that EU countries are planning to invest in the Thilawa Special Economic Zone just outside of Rangoon. It is evident that investment is where the EU’s priorities lie, and the regional grouping is all too willing to lavish praise on “the remarkable process of reform” that has left hundreds of thousands displaced without satisfactory access to humanitarian aid, left political prisoners behind bars, failed to protect civilians and even been complicit in the violence against one of the most vulnerable groups in Burma, and escalated devastating military offensives in northern Burma. It is of serious concern that the EU’s principles and policies on human rights are taking a back seat in favor of business interests. The EU should put its own standards, best practices, and obligations on human rights at the forefront of its policy towards Burma.

News Highlights

Daw Aung San Suu Kyi is voted TIME magazine’s most influential person of the decade

NLD co-founder U Win Tin warns that Burma’s democratic transition is being threatened and refuses to stop wearing his blue shirt despite threats from police that his campaign against the detention of political prisoners could see him return to prison

Inside Burma

Daw Aung San Suu Kyi meets with representatives of the Islamic Religious Affairs Council and says the 1982 Citizenship Law should be revised if it is found to not respect international standards

The government rejects calls for an international inquiry into recent anti-Muslim violence but admits it is not doing anything to stop the sale of anti-Muslim propaganda

A court sentences 3 Muslims to 14-year prison terms for their role in the sectarian violence in Meikhtila and two school administrators will be charged with negligence for the fire in Rangoon

President Thein Sein announces the formation of a government-led committee to oversee the reconstruction of houses for the 125,000 displaced in Arakan State but some local people are opposing the plan and sectarian tension continues to limit humanitarian access

Kachin civil society groups say that the latest scheduled peace talks were postponed after China objected to Western observers

Three gold miners from Yamethin, Mandalay Region, who were jailed for 6 months for protesting without permission are facing legal action again

The Asian Development Bank says Burma’s economy has grown by 6.3 percent in the last fiscal year

Burma to open bidding for exploration and development of 11 shallow and 19 deep-sea oil and gas blocks

Regional

The Organisation of Islamic Cooperation urges authorities to allow a ministerial delegation to visit the country to discuss deadly violence against Muslims

Former Thai Prime Minister Thaksin Shinawatra meets Senior General Min Aung Hlaing, Commander-in-Chief of the Burma Army

Indonesian President Susilo Bambang Yudhoyono to visit Burma this week

International

The government’s peace negotiator, Aung Min, visits the UK

The G8 calls on the government to end all violence, to respect the rights of ethnic and religious minorities and to pursue inclusive peace negotiations

The United Nations Development Programme will give US$150 million in development aid to Burma under a country program action plan for 2013-15

Opinion

Burma’s Chance to Do Right by All its People
By Desmond Tutu
The Washington Post

Powers Seek Influence in Myanmar’s Conflicts
By Bertil Lintner
The Nation

Latest from the Blog

More Armed Conflict, More Landmines
By Burma Partnership

Actions

Residents near the Letpadaung copper mine continue to protest against the project

Residents in Arakan State protest against the Shwe Gas pipeline project, accusing developers of failing to provide adequate compensation, infrastructure and salaries; the police arrest protesters

Statements and Press Releases

Joint Open Letter on Review of the European Union’s Joint Decision on Burma
By Altsean-Burma, International Federation for Human Rights, CCFD-Terre Solidaire, Info-Birmanie and Secours Catholique

ASEAN Parliamentarians Call on the European Union to Maintain Suspended Sanctions Against Myanmar
By ASEAN Inter-Parliamentary Myanmar Caucus

Burma’s Rohingya Treatment Violates International Law
By Burma Campaign UK

G8 Must Not Ignore Sexual Violence In Burma
By Burma Campaign UK

Burma: Risk of Criminal Proceedings Against Human Rights Defender Mr Chit Ko Lin
By Frontline Defenders

Burma: End ‘Ethnic Cleansing’ of Rohingya Muslims
By Human Rights Watch

Press Statement on Visit to Japan (2/2013)
By United Nationalities Federal Council

Statement on EU Review of Sanctions on Burma (3/2013)
By United Nationalities Federal Council